The Ballon d’Or, football’s most prestigious individual award, is entering a new chapter following the reign of Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. For 16 years, the award has become a predictable affair, overshadowed by the duopoly of these two legends. From 1990 to 2007, the award was claimed by 17 different players, showcasing a diverse range of talent from countries like Brazil, Germany, France, and even Liberia. However, since 2008, the excitement of honoring outstanding players has diminished, as Messi and Ronaldo have collectively taken home 13 of the last 15 awards, turning it into a predictable spectacle.
The Ballon d’Or, established by France Football in 1956, has a rich history that began with the first winner, Stanley Matthews, who received the award at age 41, long after his peak performance. Over the years, the award has seen a mix of iconic names like Johan Cruyff and Alfredo Di Stéfano alongside more unexpected choices. However, in the modern era, it has become a coveted prize, often sparking fierce competition among players, as highlighted by comments from Pascal Ferré, the former editor of France Football, about Ronaldo’s ambition to outshine Messi.
The pressure to win the Ballon d’Or has led players to make significant career choices. Neymar’s move to Paris Saint-Germain in 2017 was partly motivated by his desire to escape Messi’s shadow at Barcelona in pursuit of the award. While the Ballon d’Or can sometimes seem like a burden, it has also been a powerful tool for recognition. The landmark win of George Weah in 1995 marked a pivotal moment, acknowledging the influence of African footballers and inspiring future generations.
Despite its significance, recent awards have felt less meaningful. Messi’s eighth win in 2023, while historic, lacked the excitement of past victories. Many felt that his club performance didn’t warrant the award, especially considering the exceptional year Kylian Mbappé had. The decision appeared arbitrary, reflecting a need for a more transparent selection process.
Looking ahead, the 2024 Ballon d’Or promises a fresh start, with no previous winners on the 30-player shortlist for the first time in over two decades. This year’s race features emerging talents like Vinícius Júnior, who could become the first Black winner since Ronaldinho, and Rodri, vying to be the first male Spanish winner since 1960.
With young stars like Mbappé and Haaland leading the way, the Ballon d’Or is poised for a revitalization. The perception of the award also needs to evolve; it should not just reaffirm what we already know about player greatness. Instead, it should return to its roots, celebrating the human side of football. By treating the Ballon d’Or with a sense of lightness and creativity, we can reignite its spirit and ensure it serves as a celebration of the game rather than merely a reflection of statistics and accolades.
